Nick Carr–featured in ON earlier this year–has made another big splash with “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, his cover story in the June 2008 issue of Atlantic Monthly, adding a well-crafted argument to a growing crescendo of voices warning of the dire impact of the Internet on children, adolescents, and adults. Before this current bout of technology-is-bad-for-us (and the numerous counter-arguments, e.g., Tom Davenport and Paul Hemp), we heard the same warnings about the impact on our brains of television and computers (sans Internet). And before that, radio. And so on, all the way back to the invention of writing.
Fear of technology on the one hand and blind adoration of it on the other hand stem from the same misguided attitude—the notion that once tools are developed they become independent of us and can control our destinies: Technology can liberate or destroy us. This is tantamount to believing that the nasty cut I got on my finger from the kitchen knife is the knife’s fault. No: I got a cut because I wasn’t careful how I handled the knife. Tools don’t affect us, they are there for us to use and be affected as we choose to be affected.


Recent Comments